Research report, Fall 2026

Know which health costs your clients can move, and which ones no one can.

Medefy read the claims of four self-funded plans to find where the movable dollars sit. On every plan, about half of medical spend could still move. This report shows you where, so you can bring every client a plan they can act on.

Free PDF. No form to fill.

Cover of The Fixable Half, a 2026 research report from Medefy

The short answer

About half of a self-funded plan's medical spend can still move.

Medefy priced every care episode in 11M+ claim lines from four self-funded plans. On every plan, 40 to 55% of medical spend was fixable. Fixable means scheduled care where the member had a real choice of site, and a lower price sat in the same network.

11M+

claim lines read, every episode priced

4

self-funded plans, one Medefy client and three non-clients

40 to 55%

of medical spend fixable on every plan read

48%

average price gap for the same procedure in the same network

Five findings from the claims

What the claims showed on every plan

01

Q4 runs about 20% hot, every year.

On all four plans, plan-paid medical spend in Q4 ran about 20% above the first three quarters, two years in a row. About half of the jump is cost share, since the plan pays a larger share once deductibles are met. The rest is more care at pricier sites, and your clients can steer that part.

02

About half of medical spend is fixable.

Every plan landed between 40 and 55%. Plan X, a Medefy client, read 50%. Plans A, B, and C have never worked with Medefy and read 45%, 40%, and 55%. The fixable share is what can move. It is not a savings figure.

03

80% of imaging dollars land at the most expensive site type.

Scheduled care drifts to the highest-priced settings. On the plans read, that held for 80% of imaging dollars, 60% of routine lab dollars, 60% of infusion dollars, and 55% of surgery dollars.

04

The same procedure costs 48% less a few miles away.

Across matched procedures on all four plans, the lower-cost site averaged 48% less than the standard site, inside the same network. Every category tested showed a gap, from 10% to 80%. None was zero.

05

Most plans already pay for the cheaper option.

2 of 3 plans already had a lower-cost option under contract. On one plan, several common procedures cost members nothing there. The plan was built right. Members were never given the tools to find the option at the moment they chose care.

Get the report

Free PDF. No form to fill.

The price gap

Same procedure, same network, different price

The same scheduled service costs 40 to 70% less at a site a few miles away. These prices come from one plan's own paid claims. Both sites were in network. Members paid $0 out of pocket in every case shown.

Price of the same procedure at a standard site and a lower-cost site, from Plan X paid claims. Source: The Fixable Half, Medefy, 2026.
ProcedureStandard siteLower-cost siteLower by
CT of the abdomen and pelvis$1,585$59263%
Gallbladder removal$12,537$4,73262%
CT scan$1,375$53561%
Colonoscopy with biopsy$3,338$1,41658%
Knee replacement$29,325$15,63247%
Colonoscopy$2,442$1,37044%
Echocardiogram$1,245$71243%

Savings depend on the member's plan and the care they need.

Definitions

What counts as fixable

Fixable spend is scheduled care with a real choice of site, priced against what the same plan already paid elsewhere in its network. Some care should never be steered, and the study leaves it out of the fixable share.

Can move

  • Imaging, such as CT scans and MRIs
  • Routine lab work
  • Infusions
  • Scheduled surgery, such as knee replacement and gallbladder removal
  • Colonoscopy and other scheduled procedures

Should not be steered

  • Emergencies
  • Admissions through the ER
  • Catastrophic events
  • Primary care

Method

How the study worked

Medefy read the paid medical claims of four self-funded employer plans, 11M+ claim lines in all. One plan has worked with Medefy for six years. Three have never been clients, and they range from about 1,000 to tens of thousands of members.

Claim lines were grouped into complete care episodes. For one plan, about 10M claim lines across 2023 and 2024 became 150,000 episodes. Each episode was priced against the same procedure at a high-value provider in the same network, using that plan's own paid claims. The study used no market benchmarks and no list prices.

Plans A, B, and C are anonymized. Their shares are rounded to the nearest 5% and their prices to the nearest $100. The analysis covers medical claims only.

Analysis led by Nate Gilchrist, Co-founder and Chief Product Officer, Medefy.

Inside the report

Walk into your next renewal with proof.

  • Where the line falls between costs you can influence and costs no program can move, drawn from real claims.
  • The costs clients worry about most, and which side of the line they sit on.
  • Where the movable dollars are, category by category.
  • Why Q4 runs hot every year, and how much of Q4 your clients can steer.
  • Savings your clients already pay for, and few members use.
  • A list for you, a list for HR, a list for finance, and five questions to ask every vendor on the plan.

For benefits consultants

Bring each client a plan they can act on, backed by claims like their own.

For HR

See which costs members can change, and the messages that help them do it.

For finance

Know which part of the trend can move before the renewal number lands.

Get the report

Free PDF. No form to fill.

FAQ

Questions about the research

What is the fixable half?

The fixable half is the share of a self-funded plan's medical spend that can still move. Medefy found it was 40 to 55% on every plan it read. It covers scheduled care where the member has a real choice of site.

How much of a health plan's spend can an employer still control?

About half of medical spend, based on Medefy's read of 11M+ claim lines across four self-funded plans. The rest, such as emergencies and primary care, should not be steered.

Why does health plan spend run higher in Q4?

Across all four plans, Q4 medical spend ran about 20% above the first three quarters, two years in a row. About half of the jump comes from the plan paying a larger share once deductibles are met. The rest comes from more care at pricier sites.

Why does the same procedure cost more at one in-network site than another?

Prices vary by site, even inside one network. Across matched procedures, the lower-cost site averaged 48% less. On one plan, a CT scan cost $535 at one in-network site and $1,375 at another.

Is the fixable share the same as savings?

No. The fixable share is the part of spend that can move. Savings come when members choose the lower-cost site, and Medefy proves them in the plan's own claims.

How was the study done?

Medefy grouped paid medical claims into complete care episodes. It priced each episode against the same procedure at a high-value provider in the same network, using each plan's own paid claims. It used no market benchmarks or list prices.

Get the report

Free PDF. No form to fill.

Put it to work

Next steps from the research

B1H·2611·1.1